Cruise Ships A “Trojan Horse” To Caribbean Islands?

A recent article by author Rob MacLellan and published on the blog site Barbados Free Press, assesses the shifting dynamics of the cruise ship industry on the economy of Caribbean nations.

More and more cruise ships, design as floating hotels, entertainment, and shopping complexes, are competing with and negatively affecting the land based hotel industry in Caribbean islands. And the competitive edge the cruise ship industry enjoys is likely having a downward impact on internal investments in the tourism sector.

Mr. MacLellan notes that an almost 5:1 discrepancy exist between the amount passengers spend on board the ships verses on shore. It is a relationship that is becoming more parasitic than symbiotic, as the cruise industry operates virtually tax free in the region, yet require islands to bear the majority of the cost to meet demands for larger facilities to accommodate their ships.

The 1999 Carnival Cruise Line decision to ceased calling at Port St. George’s over an US$1.50 per passenger Environmental Levy to help meet the cost of solid waste management and disposal from their operations, exemplifies the imbalance in the relationship of cruise ships to the islands.

In light of well publicized incidents such as the grounding of the Costa Concordia and Allegra, MacLellan raises concerns about the preparedness of Caribbean Islands to deal with similar events and the resulting damage to both the environment and the tourism economies they so heavily depend on.

As such, his article is a wake up call to the Caribbean region to realign its relationship with the cruise ship industry, else find that they are dragging along they “Trojan Horse”.

Caribbean Cruise Ships – The Imbalance of Risk / Reward and A Trojan Horse

by Robert MacLellan

April’s annual Caribbean Hotel and Tourism Investment Conference in Puerto Rico provides a highly appropriate time and venue to raise questions about the future of the cruise industry in the Caribbean and its impact on the region’s hotel sector.

Since the beginning of 2012 alone, four cruise ships have now experienced very serious incidents which could have resulted in disastrous damage to the marine environment in tourism dependent areas of the world. One ship, the MSC Poesia, was stranded on a reef in early January while approaching Port Lucaya, Bahamas. The other three ships drifted helplessly, without power or steering capability.  The Azamara Quest was adrift for 24 hours in late March near the UNESCO World Heritage Site of the Tubbataha Reefs in the Philippines. The Costa Allegra was adrift in late February near the pristine Alphonse group of coral atolls in the Seychelles, until towed to port by a fishing boat, and the Costa Concordia drifted until it capsized on rocks in mid January on the Italian tourist island of Giglio.

The Caribbean is THE most tourism dependent region in the world, marketing itself primarily on its pristine beaches and reefs. In total, over 60% of the world’s cruise ship fleet is in the Caribbean in the winter high season – a greater number of ever larger ships today – but which, self evidently, have inadequate emergency back-up systems to allow safe operation of the vessel in the event of a major fire or severe grounding or collision.

Costa is a division of Carnival Group and Azamara is one of Royal Caribbean Group’s brands. Together, their ships call at every major tourist island in the Caribbean. These two groups completely dominate the world cruise industry and their financial resources dwarf the GDP of most island economies in the region.

Few resources exist in most Caribbean island ports to limit the effect of similar or greater cruise ship incidents – a serious grounding or collision could result in a devastating and long term environmental disaster. Most cruise ships move to “high season” in other parts of the world at the end of the Caribbean’s winter season and detailed cruise itineraries within the region can be readily changed. Therefore, in the event of a disaster, it is a single island government or small group of governments which will bear the full environmental and economic impact.

How much cooperation or finance have Caribbean governments received from cruise lines to even help resource effective disaster planning in order to mitigate these risks? In overall terms, what is the actual economic risk/reward balance with cruise ships in the Caribbean?

Caribbean government port taxes have not even kept up with regional inflation rates and in recent years the shore-side spend per cruise ship passenger on each island appears to have declined significantly. Today, even the discretionary spend per cruise ship passenger in the Caribbean is estimated at 82% on board and 18% on shore. While the economic benefit to island economies has declined on a per passenger basis, cruise ships continue to operate in a virtual tax free environment within the region – yet they require island governments to finance and build larger expensive piers for their larger, more cost efficient ships.

Furthermore, today’s cruise ship business model is now a highly aggressive one, operating from multiple home ports in the USA. Larger ships have lower levels of capital and operating unit costs and, thus, correspondingly lower fares – as low as US$45 per passenger per day,

including meals. Construction cost of the larger ships is around US$250,000 per cabin, compared to US$750,000 per room for a new 4/5 star resort in the Caribbean. Cruise ship food costs, liquor costs and comparable labor costs are lower than in Caribbean hotels.

The cruise industry’s overpowering competitive edge over Caribbean hotels in high season is a “Trojan Horse” with its resultant negative impact on inward investment for new resorts. This factor has been consistently and grossly underestimated both by governments and the private sector in the region. In the meantime, Caribbean hotels struggle desperately to absorb ever higher energy and food costs, while being the largest direct and indirect tax contributors and the largest employers in almost every economy in the region. The region’s governments tax their own major “export” industry, while allowing massive international corporations to make massive profits from the Caribbean’s natural resources.

Is it not time that the fiscal contribution by cruise lines to Caribbean governments more fairly reflected the industry’s impact on the local environment and, ultimately, their potential for environmental disaster in the region? If the Caribbean Tourism Organisation is evidently not powerful enough for that challenge, then Caricom governments should act with the governments of Mexico and Central America to present a united front in negotiating with the cruise lines.

In today’s global cruise market from November to April there are virtually no realistic, alternative itineraries to the Caribbean – relative to major passenger feeder countries, adequate port facilities, attractive tourism infrastructure and cruising distances. Cruise ships are currently “using” most Caribbean destinations almost for free. NOW is a highly appropriate time to end that scenario – while the cruise industry is struggling hard to protect its image and to achieve good “corporate citizen” status. Even Alaska, on its own, negotiated a better deal for its ports. The countries of the Caribbean basin can and should dictate better terms with the cruise lines, while also helping to protect their own domestic hotel industry.

Robert MacLellan

About these ads

5 thoughts on “Cruise Ships A “Trojan Horse” To Caribbean Islands?

  1. ジョセフ、ジュニア、一方で手、左この保存とすべて開始彼自身ビジネスアレクサンドリアのベンチャー。同じ、ガラスの靴内、古典的な物語などシンデレラ、それかもしれないするは難しい見つける繁体と靴理想的なフィットします。

  2. Hey! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My web site looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to resolve this problem.
    If you have any recommendations, please share. Appreciate it!

  3. 何 フォーム の 衣服 と コンポーネント されます ちょうど取る あなた 妻
    ルイヴィトン 基本 背の高いブート スニーカー? 次、あなた ルイヴィトン の履物をすすぐ 内 は ソフト 方法。ルイヴィトン の Tasmina 財布は実例としてアカウントに保持する。 のみことができます 現在 あなた 最大 が スポーツ 何か 安全。よろしく .
    非常に良い 情報 . – グッチ アウトレットモール

  4. “Cruise Ships A Trojan Horse To Caribbean Islands?
    | Grenada Action Forum” ended up being a fantastic posting.
    If it owned alot more images this would probably
    be perhaps even more effective. Cya ,Erwin

Comments are closed.